[Discussion] Good Governance Practices

Hi Uniswap fam,

Given that UNI governance is still relatively new, I think that it would be productive to think about proposal procedures and standards before we make changes to the protocol.

Uniswap borrows governance functionality from COMP and the Compound community, and I think this reference on good governance from Robert Leshner is a great jumping off point:

TL;DR

Proposals should be submitted in the forums and discussed by the community before going on chain.

Technical changes should be publicly vetted.

Proposals should address 1 change at a time.


Please share any other ideas you have about good governance, proposal etiquette, moderation, etc!

10 Likes

What does comp has to do with uniswap?

3 Likes

nothing. @monet-supply is just trying to show an example of how governance works in other protocols.

2 Likes

Great reference would be great to see Uni go down a similar process for their own governance starting with discussion in a single forum post moving up towards testing and audit and finally proposal.

Hopefully this example will show people making a proposal shouldn’t be a 2 second thing where you click a few buttons and that’s it. Proposals take time and require hard thinking, open discussion and dissection and auditing both by knowledgeable community members and then a trusted 3rd party before finally reaching the proposal stage at which point the community vote if this is the change they really want (hopefully by the time the final stage is reached the community would have known its what they want)

1 Like