Hello, and thanks for doing this calculation. We’re unsure why we didn’t win the tiebreaker, as our on-chain vote was cast on June 27, 2024, and the only tiebreaker measure approved by governance is:
Tie Breaker
-Ties will be decided by the date of the first on chain vote these applicants casted in order to reward those delegates that have been contributing to Uniswap governance for an extended period.
I want to emphasize the word casted, which clearly refers to the candidate who cast the vote on-chain first.
We don’t think it’s necessary to use an arbitrary tiebreaker that hasn’t been approved by governance, especially since on-chain votes are unlikely to be cast simultaneously. By choosing to modify what has already been approved by governance, there’s a risk it could be seen as using an arbitrary tiebreaker to influence the outcome. We don’t believe that was your intention, but we don’t think it’s fair.