Uniswap DAO Principles
Summary: A set of principles written by Atis and Erik for the Uniswap DAO.
Recommendation: We appreciate Atis’ and Erik’s efforts in crafting this documents. We generally support its contents and hope it can guide delegates.
However, we don’t feel it necessitates being written to the chain by the DAO since there is no binding aspect of the proposal or an onchain mechanism is connects with. For that reason we have casted our vote to abstain.
Governance Proposal - Adopt The SEAL Safe Harbor Agreement
Summary: A proposal to provide liability protection to a white hat hacker group.
Recommendation: Recommendation: We chose to vote Abstain out of an abundance of caution. The agreement itself contains language that attempts to bind users who are not party to this agreement. Additionally, it appears to require those voting in favor of it to waive their own legal right to legal recourse.
More broadly, this agreement presents a case where governance is proactively agreeing, in writing, to be classified as a legal person, which we do not necessarily agree with, and do not wish to endorse, since that could have unintended consequences.
We believe this agreement is done with the best of intentions, and to fill a gap in the existing bug bounty, but will withhold an affirmative endorsement of this agreement.